The Timelessness of Nostalgia
The Christmas season is a nostalgic time for me. I can’t imagine the holidays without the beloved television specials I have been watching since I was a child. Even though the animation or stop-motion is outdated by today’s standards, I am blind to any shortcomings they may have due to my love of those holiday classics. If only Web sites were so nostalgically forgiving.
A Rankin/Bass Christmas
When I think of Christmas, I think of Arthur Rankin, Jr. and Jules Bass. The company these two started, known as Rankin/Bass Productions, is responsible for cherished Christmas specials such as ‘Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer’, ‘The Year Without a Santa Claus’ and ‘Frosty the Snowman’ (plus many, many others).
Other non-Rankin/Bass-specials also form a big part of the fabric of my childhood holiday memories, including the classic Seussian tale ‘How the Grinch Stole Christmas’ and my personal favorite, ‘A Charlie Brown Christmas.’
I am certainly not alone in my nostalgic love of these holiday mainstays. Generations of children have grown up watching these classics and, years later, have introduced their own kids to them as well. 34 years after ‘A Charlie Brown Christmas’ first aired, that holiday treasure and all these others still air each year without fail, to be enjoyed by old and new viewers alike – outdated animation and all.
I called these specials nostalgic, but a more appropriate word for them may be ‘timeless.’
Bellbottomed Web Site Designs
Lately I’ve been thinking a lot about the concept of ‘timelessness’ as it applies to the Web. Unlike the aforementioned holiday specials, which still hold up wonderfully despite their dated production techniques and effects, Web sites do not tend to age so gracefully.
Web design trends are not unlike fashion trends in this way. Something that is the height of cool one day is an embarrassing 1970’s bell-bottomed disco outfit or an overbearing Flash Web site the next. You can look at many older Web designs and place them almost unfailingly to a very specific time because of the once-popular design trends they so willingly embrace. To be cutting-edge now often means to be outdated once the next trend hits. Such is the burden of being one of the ‘cool kids.’
Timeless Design for the Web
As someone who designs for the Web, this lack of longevity bothers me. I want to create things that age gracefully. I want to be able to look back on the sites I’ve designed 5 or 10 years from now and find that they stand up despite their age. I want to create things that are timeless.
I believe this is a lofty but achievable goal and I believe it starts with a solid foundation. I believe that a project needs to have a foundation that includes well defined goals, quality content and a design that beautifully supports those two elements without attempting to be cool for the simple sake of being cool. I believe that timeless designs start with quality craftsmanship.
The latest trends and tricks may get you a ‘wow’ today, but will they stand up tomorrow? Quality craftsmanship, an attention to detail, and solid (or in some cases, innovative) design choices that allow you to create something that is as useful as it is beautiful will always be ‘cool.’
Nostalgia is a Wondrous Thing
Nostalgia allows us to hear Linus explain the true meaning of Christmas to Charlie Brown without ever thinking how outdated the animation looks. It allows us to watch as Rudolph, Yukonn Cornelius and Hermey the elf dentist escape from Bumble the Abominable Snow Monster and never once do we remark how spotty the stop-motion puppetry appears. Nostalgia combats criticism with fond memories, giving us something we look forward to each year, something that is timeless.
By their very nature, Web sites will likely never enjoy the sense of nostalgia-inducing love that these holiday specials enjoy, but by focusing on the craftsmanship and details of our work today, I believe we can create something that will also be appreciated tomorrow, something that, if we are lucky, may one day be considered timeless. That, I believe, is about as cool as it gets.
Comments
Excellent article Jeremy. Well said!
While it is very hard to create something that a classic, or timeless on the internet, I don’t think it’s completely impossible.
I think some of the things that will definitely make a website timeless are great typography, excellent content, a user-friendly design, and design elements that have a purpose.
You bring up some great thoughts here, but the only concern I have is because the web is always evolving, people get tired of the same thing. I think that even though a website is “timeless,” after looking at a website for years, people would expect a redesign or a refresh of some sort.
I think the “timeless” element of a website will work better for static, informational sites than it would for a large blog, or a popular large-scale site. These big sites tend to always need to be refreshed and revitalized for better CTR and ROI. But still, I love the comparison and analogies that you brought up in this article. This should definitely be an eye-opener for many, to try their best to create a design that will stand the test of time.
Posted by Design Informer on 12/21 at 03:57 PM
Design Informer - I absolutely agree that sites need to be redesigned and refreshed every so often. In fact, ever changing business needs will ensure that a site will not stay online for 34 years the way that ‘A Charlie Brown Christmas’ has run on television.
Still, I think that while business needs and the desire for a new visual look or brand changes may dictate a redesign, our attention to detail and craftsmanship, etc. can ensure that our ‘old’ designs still stand up well.
Redesigning because of business needs is acceptable. Redesigning because a site looks outdated and ‘yesterday’s news’ is what I think we can avoid by striving to create work that is ‘timeless’ rather than ‘cool today, gone tomorrow.’
Posted by Pumpkin-King on 12/21 at 05:47 PM
Post a Comment